War: justifiable or simply catastrophic?

The global phenomenon of war distorts our ongoing attempts to build peace in conflict after conflict and in many different ways. Diana Francis looks at some of the evidence and asks if war can be justified.

Diana Francis, 21 January 2010

Wars are averted by people’s courage, skill and volition. This was the case in 2008 in Kenya, where civil war was averted largely through the efforts of a team of local peacemakers. Even when wars have taken place and have destroyed relationships and lives, there are those who retrieve something from the ashes for the survivors, rebuild infrastructure and livelihoods, and do what they can to repair relationships.

Yet so many wars do break out (as in Georgia recently), so many prove intractable in spite of constant efforts to end them (as in DRC/Congo) and so many recur (as is currently threatened in Sudan), that it is hard for conflict transformers, who know at first hand the suffering and destruction, not to feel discouraged.

Many of us are citizens of ‘civilised’ countries that have been engaged in wars in recent decades. We are used to news of ‘the courage of our boys’ who are ‘fighting for our security’. We are familiar with the language of deterrence. Our taxes, even at times of financial crisis, are directed towards war and the capacity for it. Like it or not, we too are involved in it, albeit indirectly.

The impoverishment of populations and underdevelopment of societies is the seedbed for both local violence and resentment against wealthier countries. Yet global expenditure on the preparation and conduct of war far exceeds spending to address the needs of the poor – who, by Western standards, constitute the vast majority of the world’s population. The recent Copenhagen talks foundered because rich countries lacked the will to meet the requests of poor countries to do more to help them meet the costs of carbon reduction and global warming. Instead ‘the haves’ will spend more on military preparations to ‘defend their resource interests’ against the ‘have nots’, as pressure on scarce resources increases.

It seems that money is no object for war. Military spending rose in 2008 to almost 1.5 trillion dollars, as arms proliferate and new weapons are developed. As Kavita Ramdas and Paul Rogers argue so eloquently, this use of resources makes us ever less safe, as resource scarcity and climate change intensify and inequality widens and instability grows.  The resources available for conflict transformation are pitiful by comparison: a tiny fraction of ‘defence’ and foreign affairs budgets and small in relation to those of development departments.

The fact that governments are nonetheless the largest donors makes the larger NGOs heavily dependent on them. Since the values and actions of some of the biggest of these donors are at odds with those of conflict transformation, this financial control can be limiting and compromising.  For instance, a vast amount of funding goes into ‘peacebuilding’ after invasion and during occupation. In Kosovo after the NATO action, I was torn between keeping faith with colleagues there and the discomfort of working within such a project of peace-through-war, the imposition of a new regime, rather than real peacebuilding.

How can those who make war in order to impose their will on others ever be seen as promoting cooperative, nonviolent and democratic processes? It is hard to see. As I have argued and Paul Clifford has illustrated, peace can only be built by local people. Those who wish to rebuild their country in cooperation with occupying forces are liable to be seen as traitors. War is – to say the least – not a good entry point for peacebuilding, which should rather be a means of preventing war. Once war has happened, someone has to pick up the pieces, but a glance at current realities in Kosovo, Iraq and Afghanistan will show what an uphill struggle that is.  The half life of violence is very long.

More:  http://www.opendemocracy.net/5050/diana-francis/war-justifiable-or-simply-catastrophic

Advertisements

One response

  1. In Afghanistan we a seen as the infadels, as black dogs.
    The sooner we leave the better. It is an illegal war.

    There will be no end to war unless we stop selling them Small Arms.

    Give Afghanistan a fair trade for their crops for export and they will get rid of the enemy for us.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Just The Messenger

News, Politics & Opinion

therevolutionaryact.com/

Be revolutionary. Tell the Truth.

The New Americana

Conservatism isn't dead

Psychology Corner

Everyday Psychology

Brave Girls Club

Life-Changing Fun for Women

StupidpartyLand

A voice of reason in the land of Stupidparty, pointing out the banal and often contradictory positions in StupidpartyLand, USA.

SecularVoices.org

Be Rational. Be Outspoken. Be Heard.

Art & Life Notes

Zooming in on the the big picture

Global Watchdog

Media Accountability Coalition

TFN Insider

The Official Blog of TFN and the TFN Education Fund

76 CRIMES

The struggle to repeal 76 countries’ anti-gay laws and release gay prisoners there

Kansas Exposed

Challenging the official story...

The Progressive Cynic

Modern American politics is filled with partisanship, legalized corruption and extremism. On this site you will find articles on a variety of subjects and points of view that are not normally portrayed in the corporate media--don’t expect any sugar-coating, pandering or interest money propaganda here.

Tiny House Design

Design a More Resilient Life

Modern Atheist .org

Replacing belief with wonder - and understanding.

D.A.W.N. Democracy Against War Now

|| Do unto others as you would like to be done onto || Give as you would like to receive || Love thy neighbour as thyself ||

%d bloggers like this: